No, Ubuntu is Open Source.
I don’t want to say that Jeff Gould is an idiot, but I may be forced to. By his idiocy. Before posting this or commenting on it, I thought I’d better find out who he is. This endeavor proved fruitless; he’s just some random tool who needed to write a column and couldn’t think of anything else. My guess is, he held his breath until he passed out and landed face first on an Ubuntu CD so they drew the short straw.
His argument that Ubuntu is and isn’t open source is thinner than the paper they print Bibles on. His ending quote:
Yes folks, all open source software programs should be free. But some are more free than others.
…Is so absurd it’s laughable.
Ubuntu is free. Not only is it free, but all of the software they provide is free, unless you enable restricted closed source repositories. Not only is it free, but they will mail you CDs for free. Not only will Ubuntu pay for the cost of the install disk, they pay shipping. It’s free. As in beer. As in speech. You can roll your own distribution from Ubuntu — and they even have guidelines for how to become an official part of the Ubuntu family, like Kubuntu and Xubuntu, if you so choose.
The source is out there. They never charge for their software. Ever. That’s part of their philosophy. A philosophy he quotes. But they do charge for commercial support. Well of course. Everyone does. They’re giving away the work — but they’re not going to help you run it. Nobody provides free commercial support in the OSS world. Nobody. You think the Debian people would, for free? Slackware? The Free Software Foundation?
Hell no.
So it’s not that “some are more free.” It’s just that some actually offer more support if you want to buy it. If anything, Ubuntu is the “more free” in this equation because there are more options. I don’t recall Richard Stallman offering to do tech support for anyone, for free or otherwise, and I know Linus Torvalds is too busy to oversee it.
So some people are just bigger tools than others.
